Information, products, and services for your home, office, or home office.

Planet Eagle - by Eagle-Wing.Net
Planet Eagle - by Eagle-Wing.Net
Tutorials
e-Mall Shopping
 
Long distance
  Broadband Internet
Internet sharing
Buying a computer
 

Brand Name Vs Clone?

Some people are comfortable with a brand name and a service contract. Others can handle their own repairs and will want only a generic clone. Nothing is cut-and-dried. Some brand name systems are really high quality clones with long term support available. Some brand name systems are totally non-standard. And some well advertised systems are barely adequate and not very reliable. 

The chart below should help you decide which type of system is for you. Of course, only you can make the final decision.

+ - ?

Features and their importance


Brand name computers - Compaq, IBM, Dell, Gateway, Micron, HP, etc.

Generally reliable and compatible systems with long term support.  Many people prefer a brand name system.  These may cost more than a "clone" system and support is more expensive but if you are a computer neophyte one may be just the machine for you!

-

Components may be proprietary and expensive.  Service may be quite expensive if you must pay for it.  Buy a 3 year service contract to avoid high repair costs, preferably from the manufacturer.  Many store contracts require leaving the system with them for several days or weeks, whereas manufacturers often provide in-home or overnight mail support so read the contract carefully before you buy!

+

Name brand systems are generally reliable and well documented.  Patches and new drivers are generally available via the Internet for many years, even for very old models.

-

Retail systems may not be as well built as their corporate counterparts but they are generally suitable for home users.

+ -

Telephone support and Web support are available but the quality of service varies.  You may receive toll-free support with a service contract. On-site service requires an initial diagnosis.  

+

Magazine reviews are usually available for major brands. 


Clones - House brands from local computer stores and computer shows

Clones use standard parts that can be easily repaired or upgraded.  Quality, support, and documentation vary widely.  Clones are cost effective but not necessarily a good choice for the new computer user.  Some come with no software or operating system.  

+

Components can be repaired or replaced easily and inexpensively if the system uses a standard ATX motherboard. Service may be available through other companies but read the contract carefully before you buy. 

-

Service may not be available from the original supplier.

-

House brands and other clones may be reliable but not well documented.  Patches and drivers may be available on the Internet from the makers of each component.  If you don't know what is inside the system you may be out of luck!

-

Clones from the local computer show or a clone builder may rely on cost cutting measures such as all-in-one components and/or lower grade components to be competitive.

-

Telephone support may range from excellent to non-existent.  Warranties vary widely.

+

Magazine reviews are often available for clones from the larger makers but not from the local computer builder.


Look-alikes - "Home" computers, Internet appliances; other inexpensive systems

These often look standard but the components inside are highly proprietary.  Many use an all-in-one motherboard that precludes upgrades. Typically the back of the system is oddly arranged or has only a few vertical expansion slots. Look-alikes can be problematic for home or small office users owing to potential incompatibilities and service issues. 

-

Components are mostly proprietary. Service can be expensive without a service contract.  Inexpensive systems may have a swap-out policy, which could be an indication of poor quality control.  

+

Systems from well known companies are usually reliable and well documented. Patches and new drivers are generally available via the Internet for many years, even for very old models.

-

Systems from smaller companies or from mass merchandisers may be notoriously unreliable and poorly documented, with system design changing regularly. Patches and drivers may be difficult to obtain.  

-

There can be software incompatibilities and problems installing new hardware options. 

-

Telephone support can be good or terrible, depending on the company. Check the magazine reviews and talk to people who use the system you are thinking of buying. 

+

Many brand name systems such as Gateway and Micron are really high quality clones. Note, however, that their "Home" and "Small Office" versions may be proprietary. The systems from e-Machines are very popular look-alikes.

Notes

  • Some brands such as Dell, Gateway, and Micron are actually very standard and very high quality clones.
  • The lowest line "home" computers from many companies are often nonstandard economy systems that can be a real headache to upgrade or repair.
  • We recommend avoiding all nonstandard system systems such as the low end "home" offerings from many companies, the store brands, and the highly advertised low cost brands.
  • Some software packages, and recent Windows upgrades, list a number of economy and off-brand systems along with requirements for supporting those systems. We recommend avoiding these systems owing to possible incompatibilities.

This information is provided for your convenience. We make no claims for its accuracy, its reliability, or its completeness. Please use your discretion and common sense when making any type of buying decision and when dealing with computer professionals, retailers, and service providers.

www.Eagle-Wing.Net    11/10/2002